If your eyes aren't watering, then it's not the cream. Your body detects foreign things and sends "help"
however... if it's all natural it may not be an irritant at all and you COULD have the cream in the eyes if it's an oily cream. Is it oily? If so, you will just have to wait it out, it will go away. (my cousin got super glue in her eye! It watered out!) If it's not oily, try putting water in the palm of your hand and opening each eye IN the water - it will wash it out - OR if that doesn't work go get some eyewash from the store. OR you may have irritated your eyes and that is a mucus film covering your eyes. Again, an eyewash would help.
Do you wear contacts? Did you leave them in too long? (that could do it too) - no matter what it is (the cream, mucus, contacts left in too long) it happened suddenly which means it's nothing bad - it Will clear up. Or take a quick trip to the eye doctor, he'll tell you you'll be fine - I'm sure you'd believe him over "Dr. Sunlover" here