When I first started therapy, all I did was sit and stare at my therapist. He would ask me questions and I would give just yes and no answers. It really took me a long time to open up, but in time, I did. He asked me to write down my feelings, just like what your therapist did and I ended up keeping a daily journal which was very interesting reading once I finished my therapy. Little did I know that I was supposed to give it to him to read at one point. Having said that, he didn't expect it to be detail like I made it. All he wanted, thank God, was an idea of what I was feeling and if there were any triggers of those feelings. So, what I decided the best way to do this without it feeling too intrusive was make a chart. I was far more comfortable showing him a chart than a journal! I made a chart of each month. On the chart I had a legend with different colours representing different emotions and changes. Example: If I had a panic attack, I would rate it from 1 - 10 and the situation I was in when it happened...a party or movie or just sitting around minding my own business, whatever. I didn't submit my charts until I was good and ready, so he got about six months at one time. It was really interesting doing it this way and seeing the correlation with different events and times that I had a pa comparing it from month to month.
This is just an idea that might make it easier for you to work with this therapist. Like you, my therapist was of the opposite sex, around my age and just to throw another wrinkle in it, he was a friend of my friend. In fact, that is how I got him. I would have had to wait months for therapy if I didn't pull some strings and I needed help right away...I hated doing that, but sometimes one has to. So, you see, there I was having pulled some strings to even get therapy and all I did for the first while was answer yes and no to his questions. It took a lot of time for me to feel comfortable with him and once that happened , I was able to give him my charts. BTW, the journal that I initially started for myself, was very interesting reading after the fact, but I shredded so no one would ever see it. Talk about paranoia LOL. Keep us updated on what you decide to do.